Rubric for Maus Webquest GROUP GRADE PART 1 Developing (0-3) Accomplished (4-7) Exemplary (8-10)
Components of a Graphic Novel 1) Few components of a Graphic novel were Developed. Quality was fair but did not reflect much thought or creativity. _____ 2) Some components of a Graphic novel were Developed. Quality was good and reflected some thought and creativity. ______ 3) Many components of a Graphic novel were Developed. Quality was excellent and showed much thought and creativity. _____
Images and Text 1) Images and text did not seem to match. The concept of symbolism and imagery were not developed. Quality was fair but did not reflect much thought or creativity._____ 2) Images and text matched up well. The concept of symbolism and imagery were developed. Quality was good and showed much thought and creativity._____ 3) Images and text were a very good match. The concept of symbolism and imagery were excellently developed. Quality was excellent reflecting much thought and creativity._____
Presentation 1) The presentation was not informative or convincing. Concepts and arguments were not well developed. Presentation did not rely on resources provided and reflected little thought or creativity._____ 2) The presentation was somewhat informative and convincing. Concepts and arguments were well developed. Presentation did rely on resources and was persuasive showing thought or creativity._____ 3) The presentation was very informative and convincing. Concepts and arguments were very well developed. Presentation did rely on resources. The argument was convincing and showed much thought and creativity._____
INDIVIDUAL GRADE PART 2 Developing Accomplished Exemplary
Character Analysis 1) Analysis showed some understanding of the character. The concept of “The Human Condition” was not very developed. The internal or external struggles of the character were not very developed. The character analysis reflected little thought or creativity.___ 2) Analysis showed good understanding of the character. The concept of “The Human Condition” was developed. The internal or external struggles of the character were also developed. The character analysis reflected some thought or creativity._____ 3) Analysis showed excellent understanding of the character. The concept of “The Human Condition” was very developed. The internal and external struggles of the character were excellently developed. The character analysis reflected excellent thought and creativity.____
Image and text 1) The images and the text for the character analysis did not match up very well. The concept of using images and text to provide a deeper understanding was not very developed. Imagery and symbolism were not employed in the character analysis.____ 2) The images and the text for the character analysis did match up well. The concept of using images and text to provide a deeper understanding was developed. Imagery and symbolism were employed in the character analysis. Reflected good thought and creativity.____ 3) The images and the text for the character analysis matched up very well. The concept of using images and text to provide a deeper understanding was very developed. Excellent use of Imagery and symbolism in the character analysis. Well developed analysis reflecting much thought and creativity.____
Overall Presentation 1) The graphic novel PowerPoint presentation was lacking substance and was not very insightful. The argument for using the graphic novel genre in high school was not persuasive. The character analysis was not well developed.____ 2) The graphic novel PowerPoint presentation was visually appealing reflecting thought and creativity. The argument for using the graphic novel genre in high school was persuasive and demonstrated some concepts that are not available in text only novels. The character analysis was represented well. The overall presentation reflected thought and creativity.____ 3) Excellent presentation of the graphic novel PowerPoint. Very visually appealing reflecting thought and creativity. Excellent argument for using this genre in high school. Very persuasive and demonstrated many concepts that are not available in text only novels. The character analysis was excellent. Overall project reflected much thought and creativity.____